Value Investor Daily #32

CNA Financial: 8.18% Yield – Value Trap or Dividend Gem?

In partnership with

Make your money rise and grind while you sit and chill, with the automated investing and savings app that makes it easy to be invested.

In the current inflationary market environment, stocks with high dividend yields appeal to investors looking for stability and reliable income.

Insurance provider CNA Financial Corporation (NYSE: CNA), boasting a 4-year average dividend yield of 8.18%, stands out as a notable candidate for income-focused investors. 

With its high yield, low valuation, and track record of maintaining dividend payments for 14 consecutive years, CNA Financial looks attractive. However, before making an investment decision, it is crucial to determine whether this high yield is sustainable or whether it is a value trap.

While high dividend yields can be alluring, they may not always be sustainable, especially if the company's financial health is compromised. Furthermore, CNA Financial's low P/E ratio of 10.03 raises a flag, suggesting that the stock might be undervalued due to potential business challenges. 

Dividend Growth and Forecast

CNA Financial's dividend growth rate (CAGR) over the past five years is 4.20%, reflecting stable yet modest payout growth.

 Looking ahead, the consensus estimates for the fiscal year ending December 2024 project a dividend rate of $3.76, yielding 8.29%.

For the fiscal year ending December 2025, the projected dividend rate is $3.18, with a yield of 7.02%.

Source: Seeking Alpha

The dividend scorecard from Seeking Alpha provides additional insights, rating the company's Dividend Safety at C+, Dividend Growth at B-, Dividend Yield at B+, and Dividend Consistency at B-. These mixed ratings indicate a generally positive but cautious outlook on the company's dividend prospects.

Source: Seeking Alpha

For the last eleven years, the company has paid a special dividend, more than doubling its common yield.

Financial Health and Revenue Trends

Year-over-year revenue growth increased to 11.9% in 2023 but is expected to slow down to 7.32% in 2024 and 5.08% in 2025. Gross margins have remained robust, showing improvement in 2023 and stability in 2024 LTM. 

Net income margins were 9.1% in 2023 and are projected to slightly increase to 9.44% in 2024, then dip slightly to 9.27% in 2025. These trends suggest a stable financial performance, albeit with slowing revenue growth.

Source: CapitalIQ

The company's dividend payout ratio stands at 35.27%, a sign of prudent financial management, indicating that CNA Financial retains a significant portion of its earnings for reinvestment or debt repayment. 

Furthermore, the long term solvency ratios also look good. Total debt/equity ratio of 36.4% in 2024 LTM reflects moderate leverage, suggesting that the company is not overly burdened by debt.

Source: CapitalIQ

Valuation Analysis

A fair value analysis of CNA Financial was conducted using various valuation methods, including DDM Stable Growth, P/E Multiples, Price/Book Multiples, Price/Sales Multiples, and DDM Multi-Stage. The fair value calculated is approximately $61, implying a 33% upside from current levels. 

Wall Street analysts have an average price target of $45 for the stock, which is slightly below the current price of $45.94. This indicates that the stock is roughly fairly valued, with an average "Hold" rating from analysts.

The company was founded in 1897. Conglomerate Loews Corp (NYSE: L) bought a controlling stake in 1974 and today holds just under 92% of CNA’s stock. 

CNA's ownership structure, which ultimately makes it a controlled subsidiary of Loews, is likely affecting its valuation. 


CNA Financial presents a compelling case for income-focused investors. It offers a high dividend yield and a consistent payout history. The company's solid financial health, moderate leverage, and reasonable payout ratio mitigate concerns of a value trap.

Ultimately, while CNA Financial does not appear to be a value trap, investors should closely monitor its financial performance and market conditions. 

CNA Financial may be a worthwhile consideration for those seeking stable income with a moderate growth potential. As always, do your own research and decide for yourself.

Thank you for reading!

Subscribe to our partners free:

Recommended Newsletter